1:20pm Thursday 18th October 2007
A LANDLORD who had an anti-gay sign referring to mince and faggots outside his pub has been found guilty of a public order offence.
Adrian Taylor, 54, of the Anchor and Hope Pub in Frome Road, was fined £250 with £250 costs following a half-day trial at Chippenham magistrates' court today.
Former pub landlords and gay couple John Williams, 40, and Lee Scaife, 26, from Trowbridge, reported the sign to police on May 3, after saying it referred to them and was derogatory to gay people.
The couple saw the sign, which was a blackboard attached to a post and said, "faggots and mince not on the menu" while driving past the pub, which Taylor and his wife had just taken over.
Both told the court they were disgusted and offended' at the wording.
Taylor, who has previously run pubs in Westbury and Bath, had denied writing the sign but admitted he found it amusing'.
He said: "I first noticed the sign when I was outside having a cup of tea. I looked up and smiled at it."
Asked whether he should have taken it down, he replied: "I did not put it up. The sign is accessible to any member of the public so I just left it at that."
After discussing the sign with his wife he later instructed his gardener to take it down.
Asked whether he was a homophobe, Taylor said: "No. I have a gay man working for me who has done camp nights for me at a previous pub."
Former London cabaret artist Robert Kerr, from Westbury, said he'd known Taylor for six years as a friend and on a professional basis.
He said: "I did a cabaret show for him in a previous club. It was a drag show.
"He has never made a comment or insulted me about my homosexuality."
But former landlord Mr Williams, a hairdresser, told the court the sign was a derogatory reference to gay people.
"It shocked and upset me. It was a poignant dig at gay people.
"We discussed it and decided to do something."
His partner Mr Scaife, a shoe shop manager, said: "I felt disgusted. I did not know the new owners. I wanted everyone to give them a chance.
"I felt the sign was saying we ran a gay pub just because we were gay, which is not true."
Mr Scaife's mum Carol said she phoned the pub after being told about the sign and spoke to Taylor.
After asking him about why the sign had been put up, she said Taylor replied, "It's called a sense of humour".
Deputy district judge Lynn Matthews said: "You can't simply be offensive to people and stand aside. Society does not accept this behaviour. Your were fully aware that it was causing distress."
Daryl, melksham says...
7:43am Fri 19 Oct 07
Artylad, says...
9:11am Fri 19 Oct 07
Daryl wrote:They are two fully grown men not girls!!
Being an economic migrant from the other side of the Severn, I am often asked about my attraction to sheep etc...it's humour!!!! The court got it wrong.....these over sensitive former publicans should have been fined for wasting public money......were they looking for an out of court settlement by any chance??????....get on with your lives girls...
Artylad, says...
9:19am Fri 19 Oct 07
moocherx, ex-Trow says...
10:46am Fri 19 Oct 07
Walter McCabe, Freshford says...
11:10am Fri 19 Oct 07
The Voice of Reason, Westbury says...
11:31am Fri 19 Oct 07
Walter McCabe, Freshford says...
12:10pm Fri 19 Oct 07
Artylad, says...
12:19pm Fri 19 Oct 07
Walter McCabe wrote:Walter what has that got to do with putting up an offensive sign?
Sounds to me like "The voice of reason" of Westbury might be on the Legal Aid trail him or herself. I find huge sectors of the legal profession "offensive", do I get chance to take them to the tower, no way. What about the firemen in Bristol who were fined for daring to shine their torches on the "cottaging" people in the park!
SwindonNF, Swindon says...
1:18pm Fri 19 Oct 07
Artylad wrote:But they are definately not acting like grown men, they are being pathetic. Its dangerous having a sense of humour these days, you might get fined for it.
Daryl wrote: Being an economic migrant from the other side of the Severn, I am often asked about my attraction to sheep etc...it's humour!!!! The court got it wrong.....these over sensitive former publicans should have been fined for wasting public money......were they looking for an out of court settlement by any chance??????....get on with your lives girls...They are two fully grown men not girls!!
SwindonNF, Swindon says...
1:26pm Fri 19 Oct 07
Artylad wrote:Are you saying a food menu sign that says that mince and faggots are not on the menu can destroy peoples lives and families?
As one half of a 'GAY' couple quote un quote. I'm glad about this decision.Homophobia is nothing to be taken lightly or laughed about! It can destroy peoples lifes and familys and must be seen as unacceptable.
Bob, Paxcroft City says...
1:57pm Fri 19 Oct 07
moocherx wrote:"It's Monday, not JEWS-day" ?
Yeah, it's a mildly humorous sign. So it's also ok to put up mildly humorous signs saying "no BLACK pudding on the menu" or "It's Monday, not JEWS-day" ? Come on, it was a sign that blatantly aimed to offend a minority. the humorous part is that a gay man would probably have a lot more taste than to go for a drink in the Anchor & Hope.
UltraGas, trowbridge says...
3:34pm Fri 19 Oct 07
Trowbridge Bloke, Trowbridge says...
4:00pm Fri 19 Oct 07
Artylad, Westbury says...
4:12pm Fri 19 Oct 07
UltraGas, trowbridge says...
4:20pm Fri 19 Oct 07
Artylad wrote:i totally agree message boards like this are the only place fascists can have the illusion of mainstream support
Homophobia wrecks lifes and families yes i stand by that. This isn't about getting a sense of humour,this is about a sign that was put up with words that are used everyday to undermine,insult ,belittle and cause upset to a certain sector of society. Sorry guys but it's just no acceptable anymore get used to it.I for one appreciate the positive message this ruling sends out.
Wiltshire Resident, Wiltshire says...
7:31pm Fri 19 Oct 07
Walter McCabe wrote:Walter, please explain exactly how this was easy money for Police ?? Have you been watching too many dodgy films where Cops get bonuses for tickets and Court Cases ? Granted the Solicitors probably made some money along the line, but NOT the Police. As for catching Yobs etc, you don't have a clue about the staffing levels facing the Police. If you really new, you would be shocked. Next time you see a Police officer, why don't you ask them how busy they are and how many staff they are working with. When you find out how many are on duty - ask how many towns they are covering, then write to your MP and complain !!!
You lot dont get it do you! This is easy money for the local solicitors and the police and the pc brigade and the Deputy district judges! Would they put the same effort into catching the yobs beating up our friends and neighbours in the park, NO obviously not, the proof is in the pudding (if I can still say that!)
Paris, Trowbridge says...
8:23pm Fri 19 Oct 07
jh west wilts, west wilts says...
9:31am Sat 20 Oct 07
UltraGas, trowbridge says...
9:51am Sat 20 Oct 07
jh west wilts wrote:why do people assume that because you speak out against something your also 'amongst the people complaining in other posts that there are not enough police etc. etc.' it's this kind of generalization and stereotyping that are the roots of discrimination
Artylad and Paris and probably Ultragas are all totally wrong, the offence only came about because someone complained to the police, the sign could have been a statement of fact and if it was outside a pub that had not been previously run by gays it would'nt have been worth a passing thought. Its the paranoa of some minorities who think everyone is out to get them, when actually the majority dont care, and that seems to upset some minorities even more, so they go running off to the police. the posters above are amongst the people have been complaining in other posts that there is not enough police in Trowbridge to stop people getting beaten up in the park, perhaps one of the reasons is they are too busy dealing with stuff like this.
jh west wilts, west wilts says...
10:07am Sat 20 Oct 07
UltraGas, trowbridge says...
10:11am Sat 20 Oct 07
jh west wilts wrote:To call somebody with fascist views a fascist is not generalization or stereotyping but a simply point of fact. I've said all i'm going to say on this story so thank you and goodnight.
Ultragas- read your own posts you said "totally agree message boards like this are the only place fascists can have the illusion of mainstream support" and then you said it's this kind of generalization and stereotyping that are the roots of discrimination" I was commenting on the real world, where the majority perception is there are not enough police to catch criminals( real crime) because perhaps they are too preoccupied with stuff like which is not real crime
SwindonNF, Swindon says...
11:36am Sat 20 Oct 07
Bob, Paxcroft City says...
1:47pm Sat 20 Oct 07
Yali, Ex-Melksham says...
2:45pm Sat 20 Oct 07
Public Spirit, Wiltshire says...
5:24pm Sun 21 Oct 07
Yali wrote:Just another case of PC gone bananas!!!The government and judiciary would not know what justice was if it jumped up and bit them on the nose.
Absolutely right Bob. You can`t expect the PC brigade to have any sense of humour.
Public Spirit, Wiltshire says...
5:30pm Sun 21 Oct 07
Dodgy Dave, Packs Croft Meadows says...
11:51pm Fri 26 Oct 07
Enter your postcode, town or place name
Find your next job now in Wiltshire and beyond
Search Now »
Why not make a date in Wiltshire?
Search Now »
Homes for sale and to let in Wiltshire
Search Now »
Cars for sale in Wiltshire and beyond
Search Now »
jh west wilts, west wilts says...
8:00pm Thu 18 Oct 07
Deputy district judge Lynn Matthews said: "You can't simply be offensive to people and stand aside. Society does not accept this behaviour. "
the only people who thought it was offensive were apparently one of the previous landlords ( oops! landperson), Society did not comment, indeed society had very little to do with this rediculous piece of legislation,
what I cant understand is that the minorities are the first to jump up and force their views and their behaviour in your face but a little bit of cheeky humour and..oh dear dont we get so distressed