Celebrating their own 10th anniversary, and 15 wonderful years of the Wiltshire Music Centre at Bradford on Avon, the Doric String Quartet cemented that relationship on Saturday with a performance that maintained their already high standard – but, for me, with a programme that could have been much more appropriate.
For starters, Haydn’s String Quartet in F Minor does, as Terry Barfoot’s erudite programme notes say, lay greater emphasis on harmony and rhythm rather than melody. The simple result is that no matter how well it is played, and despite the Doric’s excellent use of emphasis and dynamics, it becomes tedious – and that despite a slightly quirky element.
The Doric injected meaningful vigour into Bartok’s String Quartet No 1, memorable for a viciously energetic cello of John Myerscough which became a dependable bedrock.
For the second half, Beethoven’s String Quartet in C Sharp minor, not really a work to become emotional about or in which to luxuriate, again displayed the poise and stature that the Doric now have.
They must be mindful, however, that, delightful as they are to listen to, they are tending to become rather annoying to watch. For instance, their second violinist may well wear out in one evening a pair of shoes – such are the gyrations of his feet.
If they videoed themselves for later viewing I am sure they will see what I mean…
A glass of sparkling wine and a little birthday cake for yet another full house was a fitting end to an interesting evening – despite the lack of anything musically celebratory.